In the last economic emergency which followed the financial crash in 2008/09. Alistair Darling temporarily reduced VAT by 2.5% on all goods and services. This blew at least £12 billion in the accounts and did not do much good.
Rishi Sunak’s changes are by comparison targeted. The reduction in VAT in hospitality to 5% is at least targeted at the areas which have been most badly affected by Covid (except for airlines). Moreover, the reduced rate of VAT actually puts the UK in line with many other countries which levy a reduced rate of VAT on hospitality.
Even the 50% off measure for eating out is only from Monday to Wednesday which is traditionally a slow time for hospitality. Again, if it restarts or encourages the habit of people going out it would probably be worth the cost to the Treasury and it is only one month.
Finally, the stamp duty changes would appear to be in line with what was Government thinking before the crisis and may presage a wider reform of stamp duty where high rates have created a diminishing return for the Treasury.