The publication of an analysis by the Treasury of an effect of the reduction of Corporation Tax (CT) rates has provided substantial ammunition to those who are in favour of further tax cuts. The study shows that the overall revenue lost to the Government by cutting CT will be substantially reduced by the growth in the economy and inward investment. This is not the first report commissioned by the Government to look at the effect of high taxes and the reduction of rates.
When the 50p rate was reduced to 5p HMRC published a report showing that the increase in tax from the introduction of the additional rate was minimal.
The adoption of this analysis which indicates that higher tax rates do not bring in substantially higher revenue and cause economic damage may change the terms of the political debate. Previously Governments shied away from unfunded tax cuts because they felt that it would increase their deficit and reduce their economic credibility. If however it is shown that up to 75% of revenues are recouped through greater economic growth and tax receipts, then tax cuts become more defensible and cheaper to deliver. I would expect this argument to be deployed more to justify future tax rate reductions.
In particular the January 2015 tax receipts will be scrutinised very carefully as these will be paid under self assessment for the first tax year since the 50p rate was reduced to 45p (2013/14 liabilities are payable by 31st January 2015). If the receipts are high in that month, one can expect the Government to use it as justification that lower tax rates can often generate higher tax revenues.